CSG loses appeal in Fuji Xerox case

Nov 7, 2011 2:47 PM
Filed under Imaging & Printing

NSW Supreme Court upholds legal determination.

Print services supplier and IT integrator CSG has failed in its bid to overturn a decision which saw it lose up to $3 million in lucrative servicing contracts with Fuji Xerox Australia last year.

The company told shareholders today that the appeal, launched last year in the NSW Supreme Court, upheld Justice Robert McDougall's November 2010 decision that Fuji Xerox had legally terminated two contracts with CSG in Brisbane and Maroochydoore.

CSG said there were no specific damages or costs incurred as a result of the appeal and that it could not estimate the total damages or aggregated costs payable to Fuji Xerox as a result of the decision.

However, the termination of the A3 printer servicing contracts, in place since 2007, was last year estimated to be worth about $3 million to CSG.

Fuji Xerox had issued CSG with an initial notice of termination of contract in June 2010, alleging the print services supplier had established a conflict of interest by signing contracts with Canon in Queensland.

Fuji Xerox also contended CSG had failed to meet its target quota for 2009 - set at a combined $10.8 million for the two specified regions.

Justice McDougall's decision required CSG to provide Fuji Xerox with signed deeds of novation which the vendor could forward to CSG customers in Brisbane and Maroochydore, allowing customers to move their contract with CSG to a new agreement with Fuji Xerox.

CSG recently told the market that it had received a number of offers to sell the company, with speculation that Canon may be one of the suitors attracted to its sucessful print services business which made over 222 million during the financial year to June 30 2011.

It is unlikely that the $3 million in lost annual revenue for the print division confirmed by today's court ruling would serve to dampen the enthusiasm of any of the suitors. 

However, the announcement saw unusually heavy trading in CSG shares which slipped almost 1 percent to $1.08 by the late afternoon.

Follow us on Facebook and Twitter

Copyright © CRN Australia. All rights reserved.


CSG loses appeal in Fuji Xerox case
Top Stories
Meet every company in the 2015 CRN Fast50
Your complete guide to the best in the Australian channel.
Stephen Parker departs Rhipe, launches consultancy
Will help organisations on cloud and financial strategy.
Generation-e acquires Paradyne
Creates 1,000-client powerhouse in UC and cloud.
Sign up to receive CRN email bulletins
Was your most important vendor the same in 2015 as in 2014?

Latest Comments
CRN Magazine

Issue: 344 | November 2015

CRN Magazine looks in-depth at the emerging issues and developments for the channel, and provides insight, analysis and strategic information to help resellers better run their businesses.