Online retailer's 'reseller only' claims rejected

By Liz Tay
Mar 15, 2010 11:22 AM
Tags: accc | online | retailer | warranty | mwave | trade | practices | act | ebusiness

Mwave forced to amend warranty policy.

Online computer store Mwave has been forced to amend its website and warranty policy following a court-enforceable undertaking by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

Mwave had previously told customers that it was a "reseller only", and was not responsible for providing warranty or any shipping costs associated with replacing faulty items.

"We realise that it is not your fault if a product is defective, but please understand it is not our fault if a product is defective - we ship what our distributors and manufacturers provide us with," the company previously stated on its website.

According to the ACCC, Mwave's claims were in breach of the Trade Practices Act 1974, because it contained misleading and false information about consumers' rights.

The Act grants consumers the ability to request a refund rather than replacement for a defective item, and the right to seek remedy from a retailer, without having to deal directly with the manufacturer.

"Consumers have the same rights online as if they were to walk into a store," ACCC chairman Graeme Samuel said.

"Basically, they can expect that a product would have a level of quality and performance that would be reasonable to expect, do what it is meant to do and match its description."

The undertaking required that remedies be initiated by Victor Lee and Wilson Zhang, directors of Esel Pty Ltd, which traded as Mwave.

Lee and Zhang were to publish a corrective notice on Mwave's website, establish a complaints handling process, and inform customers who had purchased items after 1 July 2007 of their right to seek damages.

Mwave also agreed to establish a Trade Practices Compliance Program that would be overseen by a compliance officer who would be appointed by the company.

  • Email a Friend
  • Print Page
Online retailer's 'reseller only' claims rejected
"This result is the law! It even applies to the small telco sellers in the mall of a shopping centre. There are ways to get around providing a warranty - just state the defects of the item and sell ..."
 
 
 


Comments: 3
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
bartimaeus
Mar 15, 2010 3:34 PM
Interesting result! Does this also apply to retailers? If so then our recent experience of a large electrical goods retailer denying any responsibility for warranty on an item must have been outside the intent of the law.
Boris B
Mar 15, 2010 4:04 PM
Interesting story, and yes, its good to know the ACCC is alive and kicking.......but have heard Mwave rectified this around about 9 months ago, working with the government body.

I've used these guys for a loooooooong period of time and recommended them to family, friends and work colleagues and have had a positive experience each time, esp, pricing and customer service.
peter
Mar 18, 2010 9:10 PM
This result is the law! It even applies to the small telco sellers in the mall of a shopping centre. There are ways to get around providing a warranty - just state the defects of the item and sell it at a corresponding low price.
As this does not work for many retailers, then they must obey the warranty rules contained in the Trade practices Act. The only problem is convincing big retailers that the law applies to them. threatening to taker them to court is just what they want. They will appeal any decision until you can no longer afford to fight them. Then when you drop out of the action, they will ask you to pay their large legal costs.
The big problem is that there are not enough officers of the ACCC to ensure that all retailers copmply with the law.
The answer is really simple - just force retailers to display - in a prominent position, the warranty laws - and then consumers will know their rights.
Then the display of such rights can be enforced by the states.
Simple isnt it?
Comment:
Want to participate in the discussion?
Or log in now to comment


Top Stories
iPhone 4 launch: Telcos invite the stars
Singer Kelly Rowland launches the iPhone 4 at Sydney's Optus store.
 
ATO goes after eBay sellers
Reseller encouraged by ATO's stance.
 
Central Coast to host HP pod data centre
Verb IT builds 20-foot pod in Wyong.
 
Shortcutsall you need to know on...
  • Election 2010 - the ICT vote 
  • CeBIT 2010 
  • Latest iPad new, reviews and analysis 
  • How to run your business successfully 
  • NBN 
Latest Comments
"Micro-trenching was in use in New Zealand to put telephone cables underground as early as 1975. ..."
by adamtaylor Jul 28, 2010 10:16 PM
 
"If we compare this quarter against the same quarter last year, Apple only sold 3.8 million in ..."
by adamtaylor Jul 28, 2010 9:42 PM
 
"Sounds like MailProtect Spam and Virus filtering, which is provided at no extra charge with My ..."
by em3 Jul 28, 2010 9:25 PM
 
"The public don't want to be told how they can use new technology to help protect their own ..."
by Jonbays Jul 26, 2010 12:15 PM
 
"So does this mean if I want to buy an LCD TV worth $2000 and I don't have a Visa Credit card, ..."
by Gladius Jul 23, 2010 8:33 PM
Polls
Should opposition leader Tony Abbott scrap the NBN if elected?

   |   View results
Yes
  23%
 
No
  77%
TOTAL VOTES: 30

Vote now
CRN Magazine

Issue: 281 | July

CRN Magazine looks in-depth at the emerging issues and developments for the Channel, and provides insight, analysis and strategic information to help resellers better run their businesses.