Sales & Marketing
Training & Development
PCs & Servers
Imaging & Printing
Gloves come off in Intel and AMD chip wars
Mar 2, 2007 3:07 PM
AMD accuses Intel of misrepresenting benchmark data.
After a relatively quiet period in the competition between AMD and Intel, AMD has once again lashed out against its chip rival.
AMD is accusing Intel of making outdated and skewed comparisons between the chips of the two companies.
"I am sick and tired of being pushed around by a competitor that does not like fair and open competition," Henri Richard, executive vice president and chief sales and marketing officer at AMD, said at a media event in San Francisco.
AMD alleged that Intel compared a single-core AMD Opteron processor to the latest Intel chip using the Spec 2000 benchmark at a financial analyst conference last week.
The benchmark has recently been discontinued, rendering the comparison void, Richard complained.
Intel spokesman George Alfs acknowledged that Intel used the Spec 2000 benchmark last week to compare its chips with an AMD processor, but denied that Intel used flawed data to make its chip look better.
Instead he insisted that the company relied on data that AMD had submitted to the independent Spec group.
"We took their top public scores and compared them with our best scores," said Alfs.
He also asked why AMD had not filed an official complaint with Intel or the Spec on its recent submissions to the group.
Vendors commonly use industry standard benchmarks to show off the performance of their hardware or software. The data is intended to allow enterprises to compare the performance of competing systems.
But such metrics rarely reflect performance in live applications because the tests are commonly performed under ideal conditions.
"AMD is frustrated that Intel is issuing misleading benchmark test results. But everybody does it. It's a rotten system, but it's better than the alternative," said Nathan Brookwood, an analyst covering semiconductor technologies at Insight 64.
The alternative, he added, would require manual testing by the end user for each application and system.
AMD also criticised Intel for selectively picking technologies in the discussion over which chip maker demonstrates the best performance. Intel is at least six months ahead of AMD in the race towards 45nm chips, as it frequently points out.
Intel refuses to discuss the merits of a so-called monolithic design for quad-core chips, as is used by AMD. The monolithic design combines four processing cores on a single die.
Intel is instead manufacturing multi-chip modules where each die holds two cores packaged onto a single chip. Intel's design is less energy efficient and affects performance.
"All I want is a level playing field where we are just talking the truth. I've never met a chief information officer that wonders what the nanometre [scale] in his processor is. They don't care, they don't want to care, " said Richard.
He added that chip size by itself does not provide any indication of performance. As chips get smaller, they tend to produce more heat and consume more power as a result of power leakage.
Such trends have pushed data centres to the limits of their power and cooling capacities over recent years.
Alfs disagreed with Richard that CIOs do not care about chip size. He also pointed out that the AMD executive vice president was wrong about the heat implications of 45nm technology.
When Intel showed off its first working 45nm test chips, the company touted technology breakthroughs that would allow it to cut leakage inside transistors by a significant amount.
So-called source-drain leakage will be reduced by a factor five, Intel claimed, and gate oxide leakage by a factor 10.
Charles Smulders, a managing vice president for client computing at Gartner, suggested that AMD's newfound aggression in competing with Intel is mostly a reflection of Intel's resurgence as the chip leader.
"This is evidence of AMD wanting to become more aggressive in the marketplace," said Smulders. "AMD has had a difficult few months. Intel has woken up."
Follow us on
Apple beefs up MacBook and MacBook Air
Intel cuts 12,000 jobs
Intel shares could rise 25% in the next year
Intel's architecture chief blasts chipmaker in leaked memo
Aussie ERP developer wins big at CeBIT 2016
Researchers remotely pick locks of smart homes
Mobile malware competition spotted on the black market
James Cameron's Avatar producer wows EMC World
Readify's IP Factory creates $1 million revenue stream
Send us your tips
You must be a registered member of CRN to post a comment.
Click here to login
Click here to register
Microsoft partners speak on exam price 'adjustment'
Certification cost change coming.
Riverbed recruits channel manager from NetApp
Charles de Jesus in new dedicated role to look after partners.
Computergate starts 3D-print warranty service
Addressing lack of support in market.
Sign up to receive CRN email bulletins
Here are the top 50 technology startups in Australia
SMS chief falls on sword, consulting arm shrinks
Michael Dell reveals new name for merged Dell-EMC
JB Hi-Fi enterprise services head departs in reshuffle
Dick Smith reopens under Kogan
Powered by Disqus
Meeting which tech founder would leave you most starstruck?
Larry Page / Sergey Brin
view previous polls »
Powered by Disqus
CRN Magazine looks in-depth at the emerging issues and developments for the channel, and provides insight, analysis and strategic information to help resellers better run their businesses.
What's in this issue?
Most popular tech stories
7 accounting packages for Australian small businesses compared: including MYOB, QuickBooks Online, Reckon, Xero
How do I make sure my email is properly synced between all my computers?
Do you know these 12 eBay tips?
Tip: Your shop can use a smartphone instead of an EFTPOS terminal
How long will a UPS keep your computers on if the lights go out?
Photos: A look inside an NBN exchange
TPG buying highest speed NBN wholesale services
Gumtree hacked, user details stolen
IBM Australia's profit falls 60 percent
The NBN is about to run out of money
Top 25 fantasy games of all time
How to: How much RAM do you really need?
Review: Dell's XPS 15 is on the best Windows 10 laptops we've seen
Top 15 obscure video game consoles for collectors
In the game of thrones, you win or you die - and Foxtel will lose
There has never, ever been a better time to be a PC gamer
3 reasons why Mafia III is the most daring series entry yet
20 key tips for succeeding at Rainbow Six Siege
A mob of Mafia III screenshots
Star Wars original trilogy heroes and villains
PC & Tech Authority
nextmedia Pty Ltd
. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's
Terms & Conditions
Login to CRN
Email or Username:
* Email or Username required
* Password required
Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Register now!
To request a
, enter the email address linked to your CRN account and we'll send one to you.
* Email required
* Invalid Email address
* Invalid Email address
Click here to return to Login Form
comments powered by Disqus.